Section IX
That which mankind admires in a truly moral man
is his energy, the exuberance of life which urges him to
give his intelligence, his feeling, his action, asking nothing
in return.
The strong thinker, the man overflowing with
intellectual life, naturally seeks to diffuse his ideas. There
is no pleasure in thinking unless the thought is
communicated to others. It is only the mentally poverty-
stricken man, who after he has painfully hunted up some
idea, carefully hides it that later on he may label it with his
own name. The man of powerful intellect runs over with
ideas; he scatters them by the handful. He is wretched if
he cannot share them with others, cannot scatter them to
the four winds, for in this is his life.
The same with regard to feeling. "We are not
enough for ourselves: we have more tears than our own
sufferings claim, more capacity for joy than our own
existence can justify," says Guyau, thus summing up the
whole question of morality in a few admirable lines,
caught from nature. The solitary being is wretched,
restless, because he cannot share his thoughts and feelings
with others. When we feel some great pleasure, we wish to
let others know that we exist, we feel, we love, we live, we
struggle, we fight.
At the same time, we feel the need to exercise our
will, our active energy. To act, to work has become a need
for the vast majority of mankind. So much so that when
absurd conditions divorce a man or woman from useful
work, they invent something to do, some futile and
senseless obligations whereby to open out a field for their
active energy. They invent a theory, a religion, a "social
duty"-- to persuade themselves that they are doing
something useful. When they dance, it is for a charity.
When they ruin themselves with expensive dresses, it is to
keep up the position of the aristocracy. When they do
nothing, it is on principle.
"We need to help our fellows, to lend a hand to the
coach laboriously dragged along by humanity; in any
case, we buzz round it," says Guyau. This need of lending
a hand is so great that it is found among all sociable
animals, however low in the scale. What is all the
enormous amount of activity spent uselessly in politics
every day but an expression of the need to lend a hand to
the coach of humanity, or at least to buzz around it .
Of course this "fecundity of will," this thirst for
action, when accompanied by poverty of feeling and an
intellect incapable of creation, will produce nothing but a
Napoleon I or a Bismarck, wiseacres who try to force the
world to progress backwards. While on the other hand,
mental fertility destitute of well developed sensibility
will bring forth such barren fruits as literary and scientific
pedants who only hinder the advance of knowledge.
Finally, sensibility unguided by large intelligence will
produce such persons as the woman ready to sacrifice
everything for some brute of a man, upon whom she
pours forth all her love.
If life to be really fruitful, it must be so at once in
intelligence, in feeling and in will. This fertility in every
direction is life; the only thing worthy the name. For one
moment of this life, those who have obtained a glimpse of
it give years of vegetative existence. Without this
overflowing life, a man is old before his time, an impotent
being, a plant that withers before it has ever flowered.
"Let us leave to latter-day corruption this life that
is no life," cries youth, the true youth full of sap that longs
to live and scatter life around. Every time a society falls
into decay, a thrust from such youth as this shatters
ancient economic, and political and moral forms to make
room for the up-springing of a new life. What matter if
one or another fall in the struggle! Still the sap rises. For
youth to live is to blossom whatever the consequences! It
does not regret them.
But without speaking of the heroic periods of
mankind, taking every-day existence, is it life to live in
disagreement with one's ideal ?
Now-a-days it is often said that men scoff at the
ideal. And it is easy to understand why. The word has so
often been used to cheat the simple-hearted that a
reaction is inevitable and healthy. We too should like to
replace the word "ideal," so often blotted and stained, by
a new word more in conformity with new ideas.
But whatever the word, the fact remains; every human
being has his ideal. Bismarck had his--however strange--;
a government of blood and iron. Even every philistine has
his ideal, however low.
But besides these, there is the human being who has con-
ceived a loftier ideal. The life of a beast cannot satisfy him.
Servility, lying, bad faith, intrigue, inequality in human
relations fill him with loathing. How can he in his turn
become servile, be a liar, and intriguer, lord it over
others? He catches a glimpse of how lovely life might be
if better relations existed among men; he feels in himself
the power to succeed in establishing these better relations
with those he may meet on his way. He conceives what is
called an ideal.
Whence comes this ideal? How is it fashioned by heredity
on one side and the impressions of life on the other? We
know not. At most we could tell the story of it more or
less truly in our own biographies. But it is an actual fact --
variable, progressive, open to outside influences but
always living. It is a largely unconscious feeling of what
would give the greatest amount of vitality, of the joy of
life.
Life is vigorous, fertile. rich in sensation only on
condition of answering to this feeling of the ideal. Act
against this feeling, and you feel your life bent back on
itself. It is no longer at one, it loses its vigor. Be untrue
often to your ideal and you will end by paralyzing your
will, your active energy. Soon you will no longer regain
the vigor, the spontaneity of decision you formerly knew.
You are a broken man.
Nothing mysterious in all this, once you look upon
a human being as a compound of nervous and cerebral
centers acting independently. Waver between the various
feelings striving within you, and you will soon end by
breaking the harmony of the organism; you will be a sick
person without will. The intensity of your life will
decrease. In vain will you seek for compromises. Never
more will you be the complete, strong, vigorous being
you were when your acts were in accordance with the
ideal conceptions of your brain.
There are epochs in which the moral conception
changes entirely. A man perceives that what he had
considered moral is the deepest immorality. In some
instances it is a custom, a venerated tradition, that is
fundamentally immoral. In others we find a moral system
framed in the interests of a single class. We cast them
overboard and raise the cry "Down with morality!" It
becomes a duty to act "immorally."
Let us welcome such epochs for they are epochs of
criticism. They are an infallible sign that thought is
working in society. A higher morality has begun to be
wrought out.
What this morality will be we have sought to
formulate, taking as our basis the study of man and
animal.
We have seen the kind of morality which is even
now shaping itself in the ideas of the masses and of the
thinkers. This morality will issue no commands. It will
refuse once and for all to model individuals according to
an abstract idea, as it will refuse to mutilate them by
religion, law or government. It will leave to the
individual man full and perfect liberty. It will be but a
simple record of facts, a science. And this science will say
to man: "If you are not conscious of strength within you, if
your energies are only just sufficient to maintain a
colorless, monotonous life, without strong impressions,
without deep joys, but also without deep sorrows, well
then, keep to the simple principles of a just equality. In
relations of equality you will find probably the maximum
of happiness possible to your feeble energies.
"But if you feel within you the strength of youth, if
you wish to live, if you wish to enjoy a perfect, full and
overflowing life --that is, know the highest pleasure which
a living being can desire-- be strong, be great, be vigorous
in all you do.
"Sow life around you. Take heed that if you
deceive, lie, intrigue, cheat, you thereby demean yourself.
belittle yourself, confess your own weakness beforehand,
play the part of the slave of the harem who feels himself
the inferior of his master. Do this if it so pleases you, but
know that humanity will regard you as petty,
contemptible and feeble, and treat you as such. Having no
evidence of your strength, it will act towards you as one
worthy of pity-- and pity only. Do not blame humanity if
of your own accord you thus paralyze your energies. Be
strong on the other hand, and once you have seen
unrighteousness and recognized it as such --inequity in
life, a lie in science, or suffering inflicted by another-- rise
in revolt against the iniquity, the lie or the injustice.
"Struggle! To struggle is to live, and the fiercer the
struggle the intenser the life. Then you will have lived;
and a few hours of such life are worth years spent
vegetating.
"Struggle so that all may live this rich, overflowing
life. And be sure that in this struggle you will find a joy
greater than anything else can give."
This is all that the science of morality can tell you.
Yours is the choice.
|